Steel Grades for Pipe Piling: API and European Standards
Introduction to Pipe Piling and Steel Grades
Pipe piling is a critical component in civil engineering, providing foundational support for structures such as buildings, bridges, and offshore platforms. Steel pipes used for piling must possess specific mechanical properties, chemical compositions, and dimensional tolerances to ensure structural integrity under heavy loads and diverse environmental conditions. Two primary standards govern the steel grades used for pipe piling: the European standard EN10219-1 for cold-formed welded structural hollow sections and the American Petroleum Institute’s API 5L, Product Specification Level 1 (PSL1) for line pipes. These standards define the requirements for steel grades, ensuring they meet the demands of applications ranging from deep foundation systems to marine structures.
The EN10219-1 standard specifies grades like S235JRH, S275JOH/J2H, S355JOH/JEH, S420MH, and S460MH, which are designed for structural applications with varying yield strengths and elongation properties. The API 5L PSL1 standard includes grades such as B, X42, X46, X52, X56, X60, X65, and X70, tailored for pipelines but also widely used in piling due to their robustness. Each grade is engineered to balance strength, ductility, and weldability, with chemical compositions optimized to resist corrosion and ensure manufacturability. Dimensional tolerances, as outlined in EN10219-2 and API 5L/ISO 3183, ensure consistency in pipe dimensions, straightness, and mass, critical for reliable installation and performance.
This article provides a comprehensive overview of steel grades for pipe piling, detailing their mechanical properties, chemical compositions, dimensional tolerances, and applications. Detailed tables summarize the key parameters, offering a valuable reference for engineers, contractors, and manufacturers. By exploring these standards and their implications, this article aims to highlight the suitability of these steel grades for modern piling applications.
Mechanical Properties of EN10219-1 Steel Grades
The EN10219-1 standard specifies the mechanical properties of cold-formed welded structural hollow sections used in pipe piling, focusing on yield strength, tensile strength, and elongation. These properties ensure that the steel can withstand the compressive and tensile forces encountered in deep foundation systems. The standard includes grades S235JRH, S275JOH/J2H, S355JOH/JEH, S420MH, and S460MH, each tailored for specific structural demands. For example, S235JRH offers a minimum yield strength of 235 N/mm² for thicknesses up to 16 mm, dropping slightly to 225 N/mm² for thicknesses between 16 and 40 mm, with a tensile strength of 340–470 N/mm² and a minimum elongation of 22%. This grade is suitable for less demanding applications, such as shallow foundations.
Higher grades like S355JOH/JEH, with a yield strength of 355 N/mm² (345 N/mm² for thicker sections) and tensile strength of 490–630 N/mm², are used in more robust structures like bridges and high-rise buildings. S420MH and S460MH, with yield strengths of 420 N/mm² and 460 N/mm² respectively, cater to heavy-duty applications, such as offshore platforms, where high strength and toughness are critical. These grades maintain respectable elongation (19% and 17%, respectively), ensuring ductility during installation and under dynamic loads. The variation in properties with thickness reflects the impact of cold-forming processes on the material’s microstructure, requiring careful selection based on project specifications.
The mechanical properties of these grades are tested under controlled conditions, with elongation dependent on the cross-sectional area of the test piece. This ensures that the pipes can endure the stresses of pile driving and long-term loading, making EN10219-1 grades a reliable choice for structural piling applications.
Mechanical Properties of API 5L PSL1 Steel Grades
The API 5L PSL1 standard defines the mechanical properties of steel grades used for line pipes, which are also widely adopted for pipe piling due to their strength and versatility. Grades range from B to X70, with increasing yield and tensile strengths to meet diverse engineering requirements. Grade B, the baseline, offers a minimum yield strength of 245 N/mm² and a tensile strength of 415 N/mm², with a minimum elongation of 23%, making it suitable for general piling applications. Higher grades like X52 (yield strength 360 N/mm², tensile strength 460 N/mm²) and X70 (yield strength 485 N/mm², tensile strength 570 N/mm²) are used in demanding environments, such as deep foundations for offshore wind turbines or heavy infrastructure projects.
The progression from Grade B to X70 reflects advancements in steel manufacturing, with higher grades incorporating microalloying elements to enhance strength without sacrificing ductility. For instance, X65 and X70, with yield strengths of 450 N/mm² and 485 N/mm², respectively, offer superior performance in high-load scenarios but have slightly lower elongation (19% and 17%), indicating a trade-off between strength and ductility. These properties are critical for pipe piling, where the material must resist buckling, shear, and tensile forces during installation and service.
The API 5L PSL1 grades are designed to ensure weldability and toughness, with elongation values tailored to the cross-sectional area of the test piece. This adaptability makes them suitable for both seamless and welded pipes, providing flexibility for piling applications in various soil conditions and environmental exposures.
Chemical Composition of EN10219-1 Steel Grades
The chemical composition of EN10219-1 steel grades is carefully controlled to achieve the desired mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. Grades S235JRH, S275JOH/J2H, S355JOH/JEH, S420MH, and S460MH have specific limits on carbon (C), manganese (Mn), phosphorus (P), sulfur (S), silicon (Si), nitrogen (N), and carbon equivalent value (CEV). For instance, S235JRH has a maximum carbon content of 0.17%, manganese of 1.40%, and CEV of 0.35%, ensuring good weldability and moderate strength. The low phosphorus (0.045%) and sulfur (0.045%) contents minimize brittleness and improve toughness.
Higher grades like S355JOH/JEH, with a carbon content up to 0.22% and manganese up to 1.60%, incorporate silicon (up to 0.55%) to enhance strength while maintaining a CEV of 0.45 for weldability. S420MH and S460MH, designed for high-strength applications, reduce carbon to 0.16% and sulfur to 0.030%, with nitrogen limits of 0.020% and 0.025%, respectively, to prevent grain boundary embrittlement. The CEV, which indicates weldability, is tightly controlled (0.43 for S420MH), ensuring these grades can be welded without excessive risk of cracking.
The chemical composition is optimized to balance strength, ductility, and corrosion resistance, making these grades suitable for piling in diverse environments, from urban construction sites to marine settings. The absence of vanadium and niobium in the standard composition simplifies manufacturing, while the controlled CEV ensures compliance with welding standards, critical for fabricating large-diameter piling pipes.
Chemical Composition of API 5L PSL1 Steel Grades
The API 5L PSL1 standard specifies the chemical composition of steel grades to ensure performance in pipeline and piling applications. Grades B through X70 have a maximum carbon content of 0.26%, with manganese limits increasing from 1.20% for Grade B to 1.65% for X70. Phosphorus and sulfur are capped at 0.030% to enhance toughness and reduce the risk of inclusions. The sum of titanium, vanadium, and niobium is limited to 0.15%, with niobium and vanadium together not exceeding 0.06% unless otherwise agreed, to control grain size and improve strength.
A notable feature of API 5L is the allowance for manganese content to increase by 0.05% for each 0.01% reduction in carbon below the maximum, up to 1.50% for grades X42–X52, 1.65% for X56–X65, and 2.00% for X70. This flexibility enhances strength without compromising weldability, critical for piling pipes subjected to heavy loads. The low carbon content ensures good weldability, while manganese contributes to solid-solution strengthening, improving yield strength in higher grades like X65 and X70.
The chemical composition is designed to provide a balance of strength, toughness, and corrosion resistance, making API 5L grades versatile for piling in challenging environments, such as offshore platforms exposed to seawater. The controlled use of microalloying elements ensures that these grades meet the rigorous demands of both pipeline and piling applications, offering reliability and cost-effectiveness.
Dimensional Tolerances for Pipe Piling
Dimensional tolerances are critical for ensuring the quality and performance of pipe piling, as they affect installation, structural integrity, and compatibility with design specifications. The EN10219-2 standard specifies tolerances for cold-formed welded structural hollow sections, with an outside diameter tolerance of ±1% (maximum ±10.0 mm), wall thickness tolerance of ±10% (maximum ±2.0 mm), and straightness of 0.20% of the total length. Out-of-roundness is limited to ±2%, and mass tolerance is ±6%. Weld bead height is capped at 3.5 mm for thicknesses ≤14.2 mm and 4.8 mm for thicker sections, ensuring smooth surfaces for welding and coating.
The API 5L/ISO 3183 standard provides tolerances for line pipes, which are also applicable to piling. For pipes with an outside diameter ≤1422 mm, the diameter tolerance is ±0.5% (maximum ±4.0 mm), with wall thickness tolerances of +10%/-3.5% for thicknesses <15.0 mm and ±1.5 mm for thicker sections. Straightness is maintained at 0.20% of the total length, and out-of-roundness is limited to ±1.5% for diameter-to-thickness ratios ≤75. Weld bead height follows similar limits to EN10219-2. For pipes >1422 mm, tolerances are agreed upon between manufacturer and purchaser.
These tolerances ensure that piling pipes meet the precision required for pile driving and load-bearing applications, minimizing issues like misalignment or buckling. Compliance with these standards guarantees reliability in diverse projects, from urban infrastructure to offshore installations.
Mechanical Properties Comparison Table
The following tables summarize the mechanical properties of steel grades for pipe piling under EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 standards, providing a clear reference for engineers and contractors.
EN10219-1 Mechanical Properties
| Steel Grade | Min Yield Strength ReH (T≤16mm) N/mm² | Min Yield Strength ReH (16≤T≤40mm) N/mm² | Min Ultimate Tensile Strength Rm (3≤T≤40mm) N/mm² | Min Elongation (T≤40mm) % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| S235JRH | 235 | 225 | 340–470 | 22 |
| S275JOH/J2H | 275 | 265 | 410–560 | 20 |
| S355JOH/JEH | 355 | 345 | 490–630 | 20 |
| S420MH | 420 | 400 | 500–660 | 19 |
| S460MH | 460 | 440 | 530–720 | 17 |
API 5L PSL1 Mechanical Properties
| Steel Grade | Min Yield Strength ReH N/mm² | Min Ultimate Tensile Strength Rm N/mm² | Min Elongation % |
|---|---|---|---|
| B | 245 | 415 | 23 |
| X42 | 290 | 415 | 23 |
| X46 | 320 | 435 | 22 |
| X52 | 360 | 460 | 21 |
| X56 | 390 | 490 | 19 |
| X60 | 415 | 520 | 18 |
| X65 | 450 | 535 | 19 |
| X70 | 485 | 570 | 17 |
These tables highlight the range of mechanical properties available, allowing engineers to select grades based on load requirements and environmental conditions.
Chemical Composition Comparison Table
The chemical compositions of EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 steel grades are summarized below, emphasizing their suitability for piling applications.
EN10219-1 Chemical Composition
| Steel Grade | C Max % | Mn Max % | P Max % | S Max % | Si Max % | N Max % | CEV Max % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S235JRH | 0.17 | 1.40 | 0.045 | 0.045 | – | 0.009 | 0.35 |
| S275JOH/J2H | 0.20 | 1.50 | 0.040 | 0.040 | – | 0.009 | 0.40 |
| S355JOH/JEH | 0.22 | 1.60 | 0.040 | 0.040 | 0.55 | 0.009 | 0.45 |
| S420MH | 0.16 | 1.70 | 0.035 | 0.030 | 0.50 | 0.020 | 0.43 |
| S460MH | 0.16 | 1.70 | 0.035 | 0.030 | 0.60 | 0.025 | – |
API 5L PSL1 Chemical Composition
| Steel Grade | C Max % | Mn Max % | P Max % | S Max % | Ti+V+Nb Max % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| B | 0.26 | 1.20 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X42 | 0.26 | 1.30 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X46 | 0.26 | 1.40 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X52 | 0.26 | 1.40 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X56 | 0.26 | 1.40 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X60 | 0.26 | 1.40 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X65 | 0.26 | 1.45 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
| X70 | 0.26 | 1.65 | 0.030 | 0.030 | 0.15 |
These tables provide a clear comparison of chemical compositions, aiding in the selection of grades for specific piling requirements.
Dimensional Tolerances Table
The dimensional tolerances for pipe piling under EN10219-2 and API 5L/ISO 3183 standards are summarized below, ensuring precision in manufacturing and installation.
| Standard | Outside Diameter D | Wall Thickness T | Straightness | Out-of-roundness | Mass | Max Weld Bead Height |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| EN10219-2 | ±1% Max ±10.0mm | ±10% Max ±2.0mm | 0.20% of total length | ±2% | ±6% | T≤14.2mm: 3.5mm T>14.2mm: 4.8mm |
| API 5L/ISO 3183 (≤1422mm) | ±0.5% ≤4.0mm | <15.0mm: ±10%/-3.5% ≥15.0mm: ±1.5mm |
0.20% of total length | D/t≤75: ±1.5% | +10%/-3.5% | T≤13.0mm: 3.5mm T>13.0mm: 4.8mm |
| API 5L/ISO 3183 (>1422mm) | As agreed | As agreed | 0.20% of total length | As agreed | As agreed | T≤13.0mm: 3.5mm T>13.0mm: 4.8mm |
These tolerances ensure that piling pipes meet the precision required for reliable performance in structural applications.
Applications of Pipe Piling Steel Grades
Steel grades specified by EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 are used in a wide range of piling applications, from urban infrastructure to offshore structures. EN10219-1 grades like S235JRH are ideal for shallow foundations in residential and commercial buildings, where moderate strength and good weldability are sufficient. Higher grades like S355JOH/JEH and S460MH are employed in heavy infrastructure projects, such as bridges, high-rise buildings, and port facilities, where high yield strength and resistance to dynamic loads are essential. These grades are particularly valued in Europe for their compliance with structural standards and versatility in cold-formed applications.
API 5L PSL1 grades, originally designed for pipelines, are widely used in piling for offshore platforms, wind turbines, and marine structures due to their high strength and corrosion resistance. Grades X52 to X70 are preferred for deep foundations in challenging soil conditions or marine environments, where their superior yield strength and toughness ensure stability under heavy loads and cyclic stresses. Grade B and X42 are used in less demanding applications, such as temporary piling or smaller infrastructure projects, offering cost-effective solutions without compromising reliability.
The choice of steel grade depends on factors like load requirements, soil conditions, and environmental exposure. Both standards provide options for seamless and welded pipes, allowing flexibility in manufacturing and installation. These grades ensure that piling systems can withstand the rigors of pile driving, long-term loading, and exposure to corrosive elements like seawater, making them indispensable in modern construction.
Comparison with Incoloy 901 for Piling Applications
While EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 grades are carbon steels optimized for structural piling, Incoloy 901 (UNS N09901/DIN 1.4898), a nickel-iron-chromium superalloy, is used in specialized applications requiring extreme corrosion resistance and high-temperature performance. Incoloy 901, with a yield strength of approximately 900 N/mm² and tensile strength of 1150 N/mm², far exceeds the strength of EN10219-1 and API 5L grades. Its composition, with 40–45% nickel, 11–14% chromium, and 5–7% molybdenum, provides exceptional resistance to oxidation and pitting corrosion, making it suitable for high-temperature environments like gas turbine exhausts or chemical processing plants.
In contrast, EN10219-1 and API 5L grades, with carbon contents up to 0.26% and manganese up to 1.65%, are designed for cost-effective structural applications rather than high-temperature or extreme corrosion environments. Their corrosion resistance is adequate for soil or marine exposure with proper coatings, but they cannot match Incoloy 901’s performance in aggressive chemical or high-temperature settings. However, Incoloy 901’s high cost and difficult weldability make it impractical for general piling, where carbon steels offer a better balance of performance and economy.
For piling applications, EN10219-1 and API 5L grades are preferred due to their availability, lower cost, and suitability for standard structural requirements. Incoloy 901 is reserved for niche applications where its unique properties justify the expense, such as in corrosive marine environments or high-temperature industrial systems.
Challenges and Considerations in Pipe Piling
The use of EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 steel grades in pipe piling presents several challenges that engineers must address. One key consideration is corrosion, particularly in marine or acidic soil environments. While these grades offer adequate resistance with coatings, they lack the inherent corrosion resistance of alloys like Incoloy 901. Protective measures, such as galvanizing or epoxy coatings, are often required to extend service life, increasing project costs. Weldability is another concern, particularly for high-strength grades like S460MH or X70, where the carbon equivalent value must be carefully managed to prevent cracking during welding.
Dimensional tolerances are critical during pile driving, as deviations in diameter, thickness, or straightness can lead to installation issues or reduced load-bearing capacity. The stringent tolerances of EN10219-2 and API 5L ensure reliability, but manufacturers must maintain precise control during production. Soil conditions also influence grade selection, with high-strength grades like X70 or S460MH required for dense or rocky soils, while lower grades suffice for softer conditions.
Cost is a significant factor, as high-strength grades increase material and processing expenses. Engineers must balance performance requirements with budget constraints, often opting for mid-range grades like S355JOH or X52 for versatility. Environmental considerations, such as recycling and sustainable manufacturing, are also gaining importance, prompting the use of recycled steel and energy-efficient production methods. By addressing these challenges, engineers can optimize the performance and longevity of piling systems using these steel grades.
Future Trends in Pipe Piling Materials
The future of pipe piling materials is shaped by advancements in steel manufacturing, sustainability, and the growing demand for resilient infrastructure. Innovations in microalloying and thermomechanical processing are enhancing the strength and toughness of EN10219-1 and API 5L grades, allowing for thinner, lighter pipes without compromising performance. These advancements reduce material costs and environmental impact, aligning with global sustainability goals. Additive manufacturing and precision welding techniques are also emerging, enabling the production of complex piling designs with improved dimensional accuracy.
The rise of renewable energy projects, such as offshore wind farms, is driving demand for high-strength grades like X70 and S460MH, which can withstand the dynamic loads and corrosive conditions of marine environments. Research into corrosion-resistant coatings and hybrid materials is further extending the service life of piling pipes, reducing maintenance costs. Additionally, the integration of digital technologies, such as real-time monitoring of pile performance, is improving the design and installation process, ensuring optimal grade selection based on site-specific conditions.
Sustainability is a key focus, with manufacturers exploring recycled steel and low-carbon production methods to reduce the environmental footprint of piling pipes. These trends ensure that EN10219-1 and API 5L grades remain relevant, offering cost-effective, high-performance solutions for the evolving needs of infrastructure and energy projects. As technology advances, these steel grades will continue to play a vital role in building resilient foundations for the future.
Steel grades specified by EN10219-1 and API 5L PSL1 standards are essential for pipe piling, providing a range of mechanical properties, chemical compositions, and dimensional tolerances to meet diverse engineering needs. EN10219-1 grades like S235JRH, S355JOH, and S460MH offer versatility for structural applications, from shallow foundations to heavy infrastructure, while API 5L grades like B, X52, and X70 excel in demanding environments like offshore platforms. The chemical compositions ensure weldability and corrosion resistance, while stringent tolerances guarantee precision during installation.
Compared to specialized alloys like Incoloy 901, these carbon steels offer a cost-effective balance of strength and durability for general piling applications. Challenges such as corrosion, weldability, and cost require careful consideration, but advancements in manufacturing and sustainable practices are addressing these issues. The detailed tables provided in this article serve as a valuable reference for selecting the appropriate grade based on project requirements, ensuring safety and reliability in construction.
ERW (Electric Resistance Welded) pipe piling is a type of steel pipe that is commonly used in construction and foundation applications, such as in the building of bridges, wharves, and other structures. ERW pipe piling is created by using a process in which a flat steel strip is rolled into a tube shape, and then the edges are heated and welded together using an electric current. ERW pipe piling has a number of advantages over other types of piling, including: Cost-effective: ERW pipe piling is generally less expensive than other types of piling, such as seamless pipe piling. High strength: ERW pipe piling is highly resistant to bending, making it a strong and durable option for foundation applications. Customizable: ERW pipe piling can be manufactured to meet specific size and length requirements, making it highly customizable and adaptable to different project needs.ERW Pipe Piling is available in a range of sizes and thicknesses, and can be produced in lengths of up to 100 feet or more. It is typically made from carbon steel or alloy steel, and can be coated with a layer of protective material to help prevent corrosion and extend the lifespan of the pipe. Versatile: ERW pipe Read more
WELDED Steel Pipe Piles （ERW ,LASW, DSAW ,SSAW.） The two most common methods for steel pipe welding are straight seam or spiral seam welding. Welded steel pipes are typically used to transport fluid (water or oil) and natural gas. It is typically less expensive than seamless steel pipe. Both types of welding are applied after the pipe has been rolled, which involves shaping a sheet of steel into the end shape. Straight Seam: Straight seam welded steel pipes are manufactured by adding a welding parallel to the pipe seam. The process is fairly straightforward: Straight seam pipes are formed when a sheet of steel is bent and formed into a pipe shape, then welded longitudinally. Straight seam pipes can be submerged arc welded (SAW) or double-submerged arc welded (DSAW). Spiral Seam: Spiral seam welded pipes are manufactured when hot-rolled strip steel is formed into a pipe through spiral bending and welded along the then spiraled seam of the pipe. This results in the weld length being 30-100% longer than that of a straight seam welded pipe. This method is more commonly used on large diameter pipe. (Note: this method of welding may also be referred to as helical submerged arc Read more
Spiral weld pipe pile, otherwise known as SSAW Pipe pile, is a type of pipe piling product used in the construction of deep foundations. It is made from steel that has been formed into a spiral shape and welded together. It is used in a variety of applications, including bridge foundations, retaining walls, deep foundations for buildings, dams, and other large structures. Spiral weld pipe pile is a high-strength, low-alloy steel pipe made from a combination of rolled steel plates and helically wound steel strips. It is highly resistant to corrosion and has a high strength-to-weight ratio, making it an ideal choice for deep foundations and other high-load applications. The process of creating spiral weld pipe pile begins with hot-rolling a steel plate into a coil. This coil is then fed into a machine which shapes it into a spiral shape. This spiral is then cut into sections and welded together to form a single pipe pile. After the welding is complete, the pipe pile is then heat treated and tested to ensure it meets the desired specifications. Spiral weld pipe pile is a strong and reliable choice for any deep foundation or other high-load application. It is resistant to Read more
Introduction Steel pipe piles have been used for many years as a foundation element in various construction projects. They are commonly used in the construction of bridges, buildings, and other structures that require a strong and stable foundation. The use of steel pipe piles has evolved over the years, with new technologies and techniques being developed to improve their performance and durability. One of the most significant advancements in the use of steel pipe piles is the transition from traditional steel pipe piles to spiral steel welded pipe piles. This paper will explore the technical transition of steel pipe piles to spiral steel welded pipe piles, including the benefits and challenges associated with this transition. PDF Downloads：Tubular Pile, pipe piles, steel piles, tubular pipes Background Steel pipe piles are typically made from steel plates that are rolled into cylindrical shapes and welded together. They are commonly used in deep foundation applications where the soil conditions are poor or where the structure being built is heavy. Steel pipe piles are typically driven into the ground using a pile driver, which forces the pile into the soil until it reaches a predetermined depth. Once the pile is in place, it provides Read more
Standard Specification for Welded and Seamless Steel Pipe Piles1 This standard is issued under the fixed designation A 252; the number immediately following the designation indicates the year of original adoption or, in the case of revision, the year of last revision. A number in parentheses indicates the year of last reapproval. A superscript epsilon (e) indicates an editorial change since the last revision or reapproval. 1. Scope 1.1 This specification covers nominal (average) wall steel pipe piles of cylindrical shape and applies to pipe piles in which the steel cylinder acts as a permanent load-carrying member, or as a shell to form cast-in-place concrete piles. 1.2 The values stated in inch-pound units are to be regarded as standard. The values given in parentheses are mathematical conversions of the values in inch-pound units to values in SI units. 1.3 The text of this specification contains notes and footnotes that provide explanatory material. Such notes and footnotes, excluding those in tables and figures, do not contain any mandatory requirements. 1.4 The following precautionary caveat pertains only to the test method portion, Section 16 of this specification. This standard does not purport to address all of the safety problems, if any, associated Read more
Steel pipe piles and steel pipe sheet piles have found extensive applications in various construction projects, including ports/harbors, urban civil engineering, bridges, and more. These versatile piles are used in the construction of piers, seawalls, breakwaters, earth-retaining walls, cofferdams, and foundations for steel pipe sheet pile foundations. With the increasing size of structures, deeper water depths, and construction work on sites with deep soft ground, the usage of steel pipe piles and steel pipe sheet piles has expanded significantly.
